Saturday, February 23, 2013

"Surprise" Sugar Cookies and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Muffins

Words cannot describe these cookies. . .

"Surprise" Sugar Cookies



and these muffins. . .  

Whole-Wheat Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Muffins



but I'll do my best since you can't exactly jump through the screen to devour one of each goodie in, oh I don't know, less than two seconds.

As I mentioned in Wednesday's post, I baked these treats for the UF Journalism and Communications Ambassadors Blogging Workshop Monday. I co-taught the workshop with Kelsey Jenkins, a fellow JCA member and author of Professionally Female.


We had a lot of fun sharing our personal experiences, tips and TMI moments with the blogging newbies. For instance, I shared the pain food bloggers feel when a meal becomes cold as you try to capture the perfect picture with just the right lighting, angle, etc.

My comments generated a lot of laughs, but I'm pretty sure every attendee now thinks I'm slightly insane, which is probably true. ;)

Anyway, given the picture of the cookies, you probably figured out the "surprise" ingredient - Golden Oreos. After drooling over these pictures of chocolate chip cookies stuffed with Oreos, I knew it wouldn't be long before I put my own spin on the treat.

In fact, I spotted this new-to-me cookie while browsing the aisles at Target Sunday.


Birthday cake cream filling + Golden Oreo = genius!

Although I adore chocolate, my new apartment mates hate it. Two of the girls love vanilla, which I learned last week when they indulged in vanilla birthday cakes.

The vanilla obesession and Golden Birthday Cake Oreos served as inspiration for the "surprise" cookie recipe. I followed these steps to make the dough and added a few tablespoons of multicolored nonpareils to the batter.



After making the dough, I flattened a tablespoon-sized portion for the bottom of the cookie.



I added a second layer to the top.


Then, I covered the puppies and put them in a greased muffin tin, which helps the cookies retain a round shape.



Here's a look from the inside . . . 


Just. sinful.

Being a creme lover, I definitely want to use Double Stuf Oreos next time. Requests for these cookies at future JCA events are already rolling in, so I don't think "next time" is too far away.

I've also been dying to make a second batch of Jessica's muffins for myself. I love Oreos and sugar cookies, but the peanut butter-chocolate combination steals my heart every time, especially when the recipe is secretly healthy.


P.S. Using high-quality, natural peanut butter is the key to making these muffins moist, dense bombs of flavor. I used Trader Joe's Crunchy Salted Peanut Butter, which contains only peanuts and salt and costs about $2.79 per 16-ounce jar (a.k.a. inexpensive and delicious).

I hope you enjoyed reading about my baking extravaganza. Consider making one or both recipes this weekend for people you love to feed! :)

Of Possible Interest:


Hundreds of Oreo Recipes courtesy of Nabisco

162 Oreo Recipes courtesy of Suzie White's Pinterest Board

Top 12 Favorite Oreo Cookie Recipes by Picky Palate


Pin It button on image hover